Quick Answer: What Is DNA Comparison Testing?
DNA comparison testing analyzes genetic profiles from two or more samples to determine whether they match or are biologically related. This type of testing is commonly used to compare DNA found on items to known reference samples.
What Is DNA Comparison Testing?
DNA comparison testing is a laboratory process used to determine whether two or more DNA samples are from the same individual or share a biological relationship.
This type of testing is commonly used when biological material is found on an item and needs to be compared to a known individual.
For example, DNA recovered from clothing or other personal items may be compared to a reference sample to determine whether there is a match.
Learn more about how DNA can be found on items here: How DNA Gets on Clothing.
How DNA Comparison Testing Works
DNA comparison testing involves several steps.
1. DNA Extraction
Biological material such as skin cells or bodily fluids is collected from the item being tested. DNA is then extracted from the collected material.
2. DNA Profiling
The laboratory analyzes specific genetic markers in the DNA to create a DNA profile for each sample.
3. Profile Comparison
The DNA profile from the evidence sample is compared to the DNA profile of the reference sample.
4. Result Interpretation
Scientists evaluate whether the genetic markers match and determine whether the samples are consistent with originating from the same individual or a biological relationship.
What Does a DNA Match Mean?
A DNA match means that the genetic markers in two DNA profiles are consistent with coming from the same individual or from individuals who share a biological relationship.
If the profiles do not match, the laboratory can determine that the samples did not originate from the same person.
What Happens If Multiple DNA Profiles Are Found?
In some cases, more than one DNA profile may be detected in a sample. This is known as a mixed DNA sample.
Mixed samples can occur when biological material from multiple individuals is present on the same item.
Laboratories analyze these samples to determine:
how many contributors may be present
whether a specific individual can be included or excluded
Learn more about mixed DNA samples here: What Happens if Multiple DNA Profiles are Found?
Factors That Affect DNA Comparison Results
Several factors can influence DNA comparison testing.
Quality of the Sample
Degraded or limited DNA may make analysis more difficult.
Quantity of DNA
Very small amounts of DNA may not produce a complete profile.
Mixed Samples
The presence of multiple contributors can complicate interpretation.
Environmental Exposure
Heat, moisture, and time can degrade DNA.
How DNA Comparison Testing Is Used
DNA comparison testing is used in a variety of situations.
Common uses include:
comparing DNA from clothing or personal items
evaluating biological evidence
determining whether two samples may come from the same individual
supporting relationship testing in certain cases
This type of testing is often used alongside biological fluid detection testing.
DNA Comparison vs Relationship Testing
DNA comparison testing and relationship DNA testing are related but serve different purposes.
DNA comparison testing
compares unknown DNA to a known sample
determines whether samples match
Relationship DNA testing
compares known individuals
determines biological relationships such as paternity or siblingship
Learn more about relationship DNA testing here: Relationship DNA Testing Explained.
Understanding DNA Comparison Testing
DNA comparison testing provides a scientific method for evaluating whether biological material from different samples may be related or originate from the same individual. By analyzing genetic markers and comparing DNA profiles, laboratories can provide valuable information about biological evidence.
Understanding how this process works helps individuals interpret results and better understand what DNA testing can reveal.
Cited References:
National Institute of Justice. DNA Evidence Basics
https://nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/dna-evidence-basicsButler, J.M. Fundamentals of Forensic DNA Typing (NIST)
https://www.nist.gov/publications/fundamentals-forensic-dna-typingInternational Society for Forensic Genetics (ISFG)
https://www.isfg.org
